*/
Olivia Percival explains life for lawyers in Colombia, the work of the Caravana and how European support can help
In Colombia, being a lawyer can be a very dangerous business.
As armed groups on every side of the 50-year conflict battle for control of the country’s considerable resources, those who stand up for the rights of victims and for marginalised groups regularly find themselves in the firing line, facing intimidation, threats, violence and even assassination. Although peace talks, which commenced in 2012, offer hope for the future, the situation on the ground is still highly concerning, as I witnessed first-hand when I travelled to Colombia in August last year as part of the Fourth International Lawyers’ Delegation.
The delegation was organised by the Colombian Caravana UK Lawyers Group (the “Caravana”), which monitors the human rights abuses faced by legal professionals in Colombia. Members of the Caravana had first visited Colombia in 2008, at the request of ACADEHUM, a network of Colombian human rights lawyers. The idea was that if a group of international lawyers was able to hear the testimonies of Colombian human rights defenders first-hand, and to publicise their findings to the international community, this would not only raise awareness of the situation, but also provide indirect protection to those at risk. The fourth trip in 2014 comprised 68 participants from 12 countries, and followed up on the work carried out by previous delegations in monitoring both the protection situation for human rights defenders, and the status of access to justice for victims of human rights violations, in the context of the peace process which is now underway.
Participants were allocated to one of seven regional groups, each of which visited a different city, in regions right across the country, before the delegation regrouped in Bogotá. My sub-team visited the city of Cartagena on the Caribbean Coast, a popular tourist destination both for Colombians and for western visitors to the country, due to its picturesque, colonial architecture and Caribbean climate. However, behind its postcard image, Cartagena is a city of poverty, prostitution, and bandas-criminales (violent criminal gangs). We heard that six lawyers had been assassinated in the regions surrounding Cartagena since the Caravana’s last visit only two years ago.
The lawyers and human rights defenders who we met in the city each had their own harrowing story to tell. One human rights lawyer, who is renowned in the area for his work, told us that he had been threatened so many times that he had lost count. Following an assassination attempt in 2007, he had applied to the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights and had been provided with a bullet proof car and bodyguards, but in the months before our visit, the authorities had halved his petrol allowance. This meant he had had to revert to travelling by public transport to see his clients, potentially putting himself at great risk. Indeed, we know that this lawyer received further threats in January this year. Another lawyer we met was being prosecuted on the basis of false allegations that he had fabricated death threats in order to obtain protection. He had not been given particulars of the allegations made against him, and it appeared that he was being targeted as a result of the work had had done defending the rights of a remote mountain community in the region, where paramilitaries had committed heinous human rights violations. It is an increasingly common practice for lawyers to be discredited by being falsely accused of crimes or of being guerrillas.
For those of us who practise as lawyers in the UK, it is practically inconceivable that we would face such risks exercising our profession, and I confess I found it difficult to grasp the shocking reality of this situation. And yet the lawyers whom we met all showed great courage in pursuing their work in spite of these threats, selflessly insisting that the violations suffered by their clients were of greater concern than the risks to themselves. It was truly inspiring to meet some of the brave people who carry out their profession in these conditions.
During our time in Cartagena, we facilitated a productive meeting between the local lawyers and the various regional authorities which deal with cases of human rights violations, and on our return to Bogotá, local lawyers and Caravana delegates attended meetings with various national authorities, including the Interior Ministry, the Supreme Court and the Public Prosecutor’s Office. This not only allowed the Caravana to raise its concerns at the highest level, but also allowed the Colombian lawyers accompanying us to secure face-time with officials, which is otherwise very difficult for them because they are often not taken seriously or stigmatised.
I attended the meeting with the Public Prosecutor’s Office, where we gave to the Prosecutor who hosted us a list of 14 lawyers murdered in the Caribbean region, in cases where there had been no investigation. The Prosecutor agreed to investigate these and we await news of whether any progress has been made. We were able to pose direct and specific questions about national prosecutorial policy and priorities, whilst the lawyers in attendance with us were able to raise the threats and violence that they had faced. They were invited by the Prosecutor to file official complaints with the judicial police at the end of the meeting, and it was agreed that a follow-up meeting would be held between the Colombian lawyers and the Public Prosecutor’s Office to discuss specific cases.
The Colombian lawyers told us that the presence of members of the international community in Colombia is one of the few things that makes the authorities take notice, and we could certainly observe this in the way we were treated by the national authorities. If Colombian lawyers can point to the fact that lawyers in Europe and North America are supporting them, they are suddenly treated with greater respect. One lawyer told me that when she mentioned to the local batallón (local army headquarters) that she had been working with a group of international lawyers, her clients were immediately released from arbitrary detention. This is why the work of the Caravana is so important; between delegations, the Caravana continues to monitor the outcomes of the commitments made by governmental authorities during our time in Colombia, and to support lawyers who are threatened by sending intervention letters to the Colombian government and meeting with Colombian embassy officials and UK politicians in the UK.
The final report of the Fourth Delegation was launched at the end of April and can be found on the website detailed below. The report notes that the peace process offers an opportunity for change, but that the process simply cannot work unless it is founded on the rule of law. The challenge for the Colombian State is to reform its legal, judicial and penal systems so that all sections of society have confidence in the ability of justice to uphold the basic rights of everyone in society. The report makes a number of recommendations to the Colombian government, and to the international community, recognising the important role of the latter in the context of the peace talks.
More details about the Colombian Caravana, including how to become a member, can be found on its website at www.colombiancaravana.org.uk.
Contributor Olivia Percival Lawyer, Primary Care and Public Health Team, DH Legal Advisers, Government Legal Department
As armed groups on every side of the 50-year conflict battle for control of the country’s considerable resources, those who stand up for the rights of victims and for marginalised groups regularly find themselves in the firing line, facing intimidation, threats, violence and even assassination. Although peace talks, which commenced in 2012, offer hope for the future, the situation on the ground is still highly concerning, as I witnessed first-hand when I travelled to Colombia in August last year as part of the Fourth International Lawyers’ Delegation.
The delegation was organised by the Colombian Caravana UK Lawyers Group (the “Caravana”), which monitors the human rights abuses faced by legal professionals in Colombia. Members of the Caravana had first visited Colombia in 2008, at the request of ACADEHUM, a network of Colombian human rights lawyers. The idea was that if a group of international lawyers was able to hear the testimonies of Colombian human rights defenders first-hand, and to publicise their findings to the international community, this would not only raise awareness of the situation, but also provide indirect protection to those at risk. The fourth trip in 2014 comprised 68 participants from 12 countries, and followed up on the work carried out by previous delegations in monitoring both the protection situation for human rights defenders, and the status of access to justice for victims of human rights violations, in the context of the peace process which is now underway.
Participants were allocated to one of seven regional groups, each of which visited a different city, in regions right across the country, before the delegation regrouped in Bogotá. My sub-team visited the city of Cartagena on the Caribbean Coast, a popular tourist destination both for Colombians and for western visitors to the country, due to its picturesque, colonial architecture and Caribbean climate. However, behind its postcard image, Cartagena is a city of poverty, prostitution, and bandas-criminales (violent criminal gangs). We heard that six lawyers had been assassinated in the regions surrounding Cartagena since the Caravana’s last visit only two years ago.
The lawyers and human rights defenders who we met in the city each had their own harrowing story to tell. One human rights lawyer, who is renowned in the area for his work, told us that he had been threatened so many times that he had lost count. Following an assassination attempt in 2007, he had applied to the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights and had been provided with a bullet proof car and bodyguards, but in the months before our visit, the authorities had halved his petrol allowance. This meant he had had to revert to travelling by public transport to see his clients, potentially putting himself at great risk. Indeed, we know that this lawyer received further threats in January this year. Another lawyer we met was being prosecuted on the basis of false allegations that he had fabricated death threats in order to obtain protection. He had not been given particulars of the allegations made against him, and it appeared that he was being targeted as a result of the work had had done defending the rights of a remote mountain community in the region, where paramilitaries had committed heinous human rights violations. It is an increasingly common practice for lawyers to be discredited by being falsely accused of crimes or of being guerrillas.
For those of us who practise as lawyers in the UK, it is practically inconceivable that we would face such risks exercising our profession, and I confess I found it difficult to grasp the shocking reality of this situation. And yet the lawyers whom we met all showed great courage in pursuing their work in spite of these threats, selflessly insisting that the violations suffered by their clients were of greater concern than the risks to themselves. It was truly inspiring to meet some of the brave people who carry out their profession in these conditions.
During our time in Cartagena, we facilitated a productive meeting between the local lawyers and the various regional authorities which deal with cases of human rights violations, and on our return to Bogotá, local lawyers and Caravana delegates attended meetings with various national authorities, including the Interior Ministry, the Supreme Court and the Public Prosecutor’s Office. This not only allowed the Caravana to raise its concerns at the highest level, but also allowed the Colombian lawyers accompanying us to secure face-time with officials, which is otherwise very difficult for them because they are often not taken seriously or stigmatised.
I attended the meeting with the Public Prosecutor’s Office, where we gave to the Prosecutor who hosted us a list of 14 lawyers murdered in the Caribbean region, in cases where there had been no investigation. The Prosecutor agreed to investigate these and we await news of whether any progress has been made. We were able to pose direct and specific questions about national prosecutorial policy and priorities, whilst the lawyers in attendance with us were able to raise the threats and violence that they had faced. They were invited by the Prosecutor to file official complaints with the judicial police at the end of the meeting, and it was agreed that a follow-up meeting would be held between the Colombian lawyers and the Public Prosecutor’s Office to discuss specific cases.
The Colombian lawyers told us that the presence of members of the international community in Colombia is one of the few things that makes the authorities take notice, and we could certainly observe this in the way we were treated by the national authorities. If Colombian lawyers can point to the fact that lawyers in Europe and North America are supporting them, they are suddenly treated with greater respect. One lawyer told me that when she mentioned to the local batallón (local army headquarters) that she had been working with a group of international lawyers, her clients were immediately released from arbitrary detention. This is why the work of the Caravana is so important; between delegations, the Caravana continues to monitor the outcomes of the commitments made by governmental authorities during our time in Colombia, and to support lawyers who are threatened by sending intervention letters to the Colombian government and meeting with Colombian embassy officials and UK politicians in the UK.
The final report of the Fourth Delegation was launched at the end of April and can be found on the website detailed below. The report notes that the peace process offers an opportunity for change, but that the process simply cannot work unless it is founded on the rule of law. The challenge for the Colombian State is to reform its legal, judicial and penal systems so that all sections of society have confidence in the ability of justice to uphold the basic rights of everyone in society. The report makes a number of recommendations to the Colombian government, and to the international community, recognising the important role of the latter in the context of the peace talks.
More details about the Colombian Caravana, including how to become a member, can be found on its website at www.colombiancaravana.org.uk.
Contributor Olivia Percival Lawyer, Primary Care and Public Health Team, DH Legal Advisers, Government Legal Department
Olivia Percival explains life for lawyers in Colombia, the work of the Caravana and how European support can help
In Colombia, being a lawyer can be a very dangerous business.
Sam Townend KC explains the Bar Council’s efforts towards ensuring a bright future for the profession
Giovanni D’Avola explores the issue of over-citation of unreported cases and the ‘added value’ elements of a law report
Louise Crush explores the key points and opportunities for tax efficiency
Westgate Wealth Management Ltd is a Partner Practice of FTSE 100 company St. James’s Place – one of the top UK Wealth Management firms. We offer a holistic service of distinct quality, integrity, and excellence with the aim to build a professional and valuable relationship with our clients, helping to provide them with security now, prosperity in the future and the highest standard of service in all of our dealings.
Is now the time to review your financial position, having reached a career milestone? asks Louise Crush
If you were to host a dinner party with 10 guests, and you asked them to explain what financial planning is and how it differs to financial advice, you’d receive 10 different answers. The variety of answers highlights the ongoing need to clarify and promote the value of financial planning.
Most of us like to think we would risk our career in order to meet our ethical obligations, so why have so many lawyers failed to hold the line? asks Flora Page
If your current practice environment is bringing you down, seek a new one. However daunting the change, it will be worth it, says Anon Barrister
Creating advocacy opportunities for juniors is now the expectation but not always easy to put into effect. Tom Mitcheson KC distils developing best practice from the Patents Court initiative already bearing fruit
Sam Townend KC explains the Bar Council’s efforts towards ensuring a bright future for the profession
The long-running fee-paid judicial pensions saga continues. The current cut-off date for giving notice of election to join FPJPS is 31 March 2024, and that date now gives rise to a serious problem, warns HH John Platt