*/
The President of the Family Division has again described as “unprincipled and unconscionable” the complexity and delays involved in obtaining legal aid for parents who lack capacity.
In this already widely reported case, the local authority sought to place a young child for adoption.
Neither parent could get legal representation although the mother had borderline learning difficulties and the father had an IQ of 50 and would apparently need an intermediary even to give instructions.
The matter has come back as In re D (a Child) 2 [2015] EWFC 2. Both parents have now secured legal aid funding up to the final hearing, subject to monthly contributions, but the case underlines the difficulties in securing public funding for legal representation.
Sir James Munby said it was “no thanks to the system” that the parents were able to avail themselves of that assistance, but due to the “goodwill... of the legal profession... far above and far beyond the call of duty”.
“For any parent who lacks capacity the application process itself functions as a barrier to access to public funding which, in the context of a placement application, involves a potential breach of Art 6,” he said.
The parents could be “forgiven for thinking that they are trapped in a system which is neither compassionate nor even humane”. Noting that the primary focus of the hearings to date had been legal aid rather than the welfare of D, Sir James added: “Is this really the best we can do?”
Neither parent could get legal representation although the mother had borderline learning difficulties and the father had an IQ of 50 and would apparently need an intermediary even to give instructions.
The matter has come back as In re D (a Child) 2 [2015] EWFC 2. Both parents have now secured legal aid funding up to the final hearing, subject to monthly contributions, but the case underlines the difficulties in securing public funding for legal representation.
Sir James Munby said it was “no thanks to the system” that the parents were able to avail themselves of that assistance, but due to the “goodwill... of the legal profession... far above and far beyond the call of duty”.
“For any parent who lacks capacity the application process itself functions as a barrier to access to public funding which, in the context of a placement application, involves a potential breach of Art 6,” he said.
The parents could be “forgiven for thinking that they are trapped in a system which is neither compassionate nor even humane”. Noting that the primary focus of the hearings to date had been legal aid rather than the welfare of D, Sir James added: “Is this really the best we can do?”
The President of the Family Division has again described as “unprincipled and unconscionable” the complexity and delays involved in obtaining legal aid for parents who lack capacity.
In this already widely reported case, the local authority sought to place a young child for adoption.
Chair of the Bar reflects on 2025
Q&A with criminal barrister Nick Murphy, who moved to New Park Court Chambers on the North Eastern Circuit in search of a better work-life balance
Revolt Cycling in Holborn, London’s first sustainable fitness studio, invites barristers to join the revolution – turning pedal power into clean energy
Rachel Davenport, Co-founder and Director at AlphaBiolabs, reflects on how the company’s Giving Back ethos continues to make a difference to communities across the UK
By Marie Law, Director of Toxicology at AlphaBiolabs
AlphaBiolabs has made a £500 donation to Sean’s Place, a men’s mental health charity based in Sefton, as part of its ongoing Giving Back initiative
Oscar Davies shares their lessons learnt
Little has changed since Burns v Burns . Cohabiting couples deserve better than to be left on the blasted heath with the existing witch’s brew for another four decades, argues Christopher Stirling
Six months of court observation at the Old Bailey: APPEAL’s Dr Nisha Waller and Tehreem Sultan report their findings on prosecution practices under joint enterprise
Despite its prevalence, autism spectrum disorder remains poorly understood in the criminal justice system. Does Alex Henry’s joint enterprise conviction expose the need to audit prisons? asks Dr Felicity Gerry KC
With automation now deeply embedded in the Department for Work Pensions, Alexander McColl and Alexa Thompson review what we know, what we don’t and avenues for legal challenge
